Oh am I glad I deleted what I typed last night after reading PJam's post. You all answered in such a nice logical fashion. No the FFE isn't a one size fits all. It isn't a car for everybody. But oh boy do I ever love the three cars we own now.
My path flipped upside down from ElSupreme's. We bought an FFE because about two years ago my wife said in passing - wouldn't it be nice to have a Nissan Leaf that I could drive to school every day? She teaches Advanced Placement Environmental Science at the second largest high school in Chicago. Well, yes it would. And yes it would be natural that we should own one of those cars.
I test drove the Tesla. Loved it. Configured it. Came home and said, can we get one? How much are they - well it will be around $90,000. Nope, won't drive that to school, can't do it every day. You can get it for a toy, but I won't drive it. So I did some research. Wow, Ford has an electric, and our dealer 10 steps from our house has one! I'm going down to drive it today.
Fell in love with it on the spot. My wife drove it and loved it. We bought it. That meant we had four cars - a 1999 Mercedes E320, a 2002 Buick Rendezvous, and a 2012 Focus Titanium.
That all worked for a while. The Mercedes was rusting everywhere. Fast forward a year (a totaled FFE and leasing a new one) and I figured out I could afford a Model S. Test drove it, configured it and ordered it. The caveat, one car had to go - we couldn't have 5. The Mercedes was it - I had to limp it over to Car Max hoping some light wouldn't come on.
After owning the Tesla for a while and one son going off to college - we decided the Rendezvous had to go (it had blown a head gasket twice, had super bad random no start problems - stranded my wife and son many times, and had thrown the wheel sensor error again for the last time). Now we have three cars. Two electric and one ICE.
The long answer to PJam's rant about their FFE. In the five or six months I've owned the Tesla - it now has 10,000 miles on it. I have never drive a car so much in such a short time in my life. It is the car we use to go everywhere outside of daily commute. The FFE goes to school every day. The ICE Focus is for number 1 son to take to graduate classes in Chicago and his random trip to see friends. It now gets almost 30 MPG on the highway. And I use the Tesla for whatever I want to do. It is going to spend a lot of time between Chicago and Muncie, IN watching my son play volleyball.
Which car do we prefer to drive - FFE for around town. Tesla for trips. It is simple.
No ElSupreme and I are not average car buyers. But we aren't that out of the norm. Once you've tasted electric cars, you want nothing else. Gas cars are not as pleasurable to drive by a long measure.
And if a person only owned one car and it was an FFE - that person can rent cars for longer trips. People that use public transportation for their daily commute do it ALL the time. They rent cars when they need to go farther. It isn't complicated or that strange.